Natural Order Hypothesis: Meaning and Examples

The TortoLingua turtle points to English words above an open book.

Natural Order Hypothesis: meaning and an example

The Natural Order Hypothesis proposes that some grammatical features tend to develop earlier than others, rather than simply following textbook order. Krashen discusses patterns observed across groups of learners, especially in English. They are tendencies, not a fixed timetable for every person or language.

For example, a learner may use -ing in “I am reading” while still omitting third-person -s in “She reads.” Knowing how to explain a rule and using it reliably in conversation are different things. This example does not establish why a particular learner made an error, or prove that more reading alone will resolve it.

Try reading in context

See a grammar form in a short text.

Read a short text and mark words you do not know. The app uses your marks to choose the next text automatically; if the current text is too difficult, it offers a simpler one.

Where the idea comes from

In Principles and Practice in Second Language Acquisition (1982), Stephen Krashen brings together studies of English grammatical morphemes: small forms such as plural -s, past-tense -ed and articles.

He discusses Brown’s work on children acquiring English as their first language, Dulay and Burt’s studies of children learning English as a second language, and Bailey, Madden and Krashen’s work with adults. First-language and second-language findings are not identical. Krashen also explicitly acknowledges differences between individual learners.

His table on printed page 13 presents an average order for English as a second language. It does not specify an order between features grouped in the same box. Treating it as a checklist of stages that everyone must finish one by one would change the claim.

English forms that make the question visible

FormExampleRole in this example
Progressive -ing“I am reading.”Reading is in progress: I am reading now.
Plural -s“two books”There is more than one book.
Third-person singular -s“She reads.”Reads is the third-person singular form of read in the present simple.
Possessive -’s“Maria’s book”The book belongs to Maria.
Irregular and regular past“went”; “walked”Went is the irregular past of go; walked is the regular past of walk.

Krashen’s discussion places progressive -ing and plural -s among earlier forms and third-person and possessive -s among later ones. These examples illustrate the research question; they are not an instruction to postpone teaching a useful form.

Acquisition order is not a lesson plan

An order observed across learners and a sequence chosen by a teacher answer different questions. A course may introduce a form because it helps you describe something you need now. A study may rank forms by accuracy in a particular task. Those observations do not by themselves show that an explanation is useless or that instruction can never affect development.

Krashen himself cautions against turning his average order into a syllabus that teaches -ing early and third-person -s late. A further distinction is important: order across features is not the same as stages within one feature, such as changes in how a learner forms questions.

One mistake cannot tell you whether you are ready to acquire a form. If you know a rule but miss it in conversation, compare examples and seek feedback before deciding what practice would help.

Why the evidence needs limits

Keep three questions separate when you encounter a claim about a “natural order”:

  • Who was studied? Children learning their first language are not the same population as adults learning another one.
  • What was measured? Correct answers on a task, first appearances of a form and reliable use across situations are different outcomes.
  • Which language and feature? Results about selected English morphemes do not establish a single order for all grammar, German word order or Spanish mood.

Group averages can also conceal differences between people. An apparent mismatch with an average does not tell you that you have failed, and a match does not predict when you will master the next form. Language-learning timelines need the same distinction between an orientation and a personal forecast.

How this connects to input and attention

Krashen links natural order to i+1: the current stage i and the following stage +1. In his Input Hypothesis, understanding language with structures just beyond what the learner has already acquired is necessary but not sufficient for acquisition. It is not a method for selecting the exact next grammar point from a page.

Another theoretical perspective, Schmidt (1990), examines awareness and noticing in language learning. These accounts ask different questions about how learners process language; neither should become a promise that grammar will take care of itself if you follow a routine.

As a practical option, read a passage you can follow and look at how a troublesome form is used. If an explanation helps, use it. If your goal is to say or write something, include that activity and appropriate feedback. For the reading method, see learning a language by reading and the background on extensive reading.

A useful next step, without a grammar deadline

Choose one sentence in a text you want to read. Ask what it means, then examine the form that interests or confuses you. You can reread it, compare another example or leave it for later. There is no required daily duration or deadline for making the rule automatic. If you want help fitting reading around your life, the consistency guide offers a related starting point; you still decide when and how much to read.

In TortoLingua, mark words you do not know. The app chooses the next text automatically from your marks; if the current text is too difficult, it offers a simpler one. It does not ask you to select a developmental grammar stage, and that adaptation is not proof of Krashen’s theory.

Sources and scope

The account of the hypothesis and its average order follows Krashen (1982), printed pages 12–14. The distinction between a group tendency and an individual diagnosis is essential to how the examples are used here. Schmidt’s paper supplies a separate theoretical discussion of awareness, not a guaranteed recipe. The reading suggestions are editorial options, not a validated teaching method or a claim that input always outperforms grammar practice.

Last updated